Hodgson, not Redknapp – A Scottish Perspective
Roy Hodgson - the smart choice for England
First up, I’m not an England fan. But then neither is Rafael Hönigstein an England fan, and he wrote an entire book on the travails and peculiarities of the football in that country, ‘Englischer Fussball’, so I’m hoping that will allow me some scope to crave the reader’s indulgence for a thousand words or so on the subject, at least they will have the virtue of being in English. I suppose neither Hönigstein nor me could really care less who the F.A. appoint as the next England manager, but while Rafa’s lofty, dispassionate equanimity on the subject would be Teutonic in origin, mine is of an even older, more traditional footballing rival, being Caledonian in its nature.
Yes I know Scotland have a rubbish manager too, who thinks it’s clever to experiment in a competitive game with no strikers in his formation against a decent, but nowhere near as good as they once were, Czech team, ( a costly error that will surely haunt Craig Levein for what’s left of his managerial career). And it’s true, we have a poor team too, which hasn’t even managed to qualify for a major tournament since Craig Brown took us to the World Cup in France back in 1998, a tournament that, if at all, is dimly remembered by our present crop of players alongside short trousers and their four times table. At least I can’t be accused of gloating at the latest misfortune to affect the English game, because in Scotland we’d give our left foot to have their problems right now. Nevertheless, here is the basis of my contention and the purpose behind this article: Harry Redknapp, sorry I just don’t see it as the right choice.
Let’s backtrack a wee minute so we can remind ourselves how we came to be in this situation. It’s said that most plane crashes are a series of mistakes, a chain of avoidable errors, any one of which, had they been spotted in time, could have prevented the accident. Let’s take these errors in turn then: John Terry, the England captain, (allegedly) racially abuses a black player, using the unutterable ‘N’ word (allegedly, allegedly, I must stress allegedly), and not just any old black player. But Anton Ferdinand, the brother of his erstwhile international central defensive partner, Rio Ferdinand, his sometime rival for the armband itself – calamity number one. Calamity number two: a court date has been pencilled in for March, but guess what, Terry’s club don’t want it interfering with their challenge for honours (what honours?), so the date of the hearing is put back. A lot of people don’t find it convenient to come to court, protests the judge, while at the same time agreeing to the delay – July, we hear, is when the case will be heard. But wait, here comes calamity number three, because the European Championships are being held this summer, and doesn’t that mean that the tournament will take place with a potentially divisive charge of racial abuse hanging over the man who will not only lead the team onto the field but wear the armband as well? This is England remember, where the captaincy matters, it’s not just passed around amongst the senior pros willy-nilly. This is the land of upstanding leaders, of fairness and justice and of absolutely zero tolerance to anything untoward in a racial context, where Sepp Blatter is battered from pillar to post for his injudicious words on the subject and where Luis Suarez is given an eight game ban for calling a man a ‘negro’, nothing other than a bit of jocular, if somewhat politically incorrect, banter back in his homeland, he contends. Sorry son, zero tolerance here, this is England, you’re barred. Calamity number four, panic engulfs the F.A. Think of the press reaction. Forget innocent until proven guilty, the media will be all over this, and the media are the ones who pay the bills in England, so we can’t be doing with that. We have to keep our paymasters onside, which leads neatly on to calamity number five: somewhere in the F.A. statutes it says the board have the right determine if the England captain continues in his job. So in a panic they fire him, without telling Capello, who promptly takes the huff and walks out.
At this point in the writing of this article, I feel I need to go back and reread what I’ve written so far, just to make sure that I haven’t made it all up. I’m really not gloating, honest, because Scotland has a far poorer team than England will ever have, and at least the English are going to Poland and Ukraine, unlike the Scots who need to broaden the tournament to twenty-four teams to give themselves half a chance of even qualifying, but if these events seem to have a strangely familiar ring to them, it must be because it’s déjà vu all over again. There’s another brilliant book about English football called ‘Why England lose’ by Simon Kuper and Stefan Szymanski, but as far as I’m concerned this sorry series of calamities will tell you everything you need to know on the subject. Inevitably Capello’s departure was followed by clamourings to ensure that the next manager was an Englishman, an echo of Gordon Brown’s ill-fated (and frankly illegal) call for ‘British jobs for British workers’. Be careful what you wish for; the last time a foreigner left the England post he was also followed by the same demands. Felipe Scolari was in contention after Eriksson left, a man who had won a World Cup, but in the end the job went to Englishman Steve McClaren, a man who’d won a League Cup. McClaren failed to qualify England for the Euros in 2008; in contrast his successor Capello has a record in competitive matches that is unsurpassed by any England manager in history.
Harry Not the best man for the job
The problem seems to me to be twofold: there don’t seem to be too many good English managers out there. The Premier League is full of Scotsmen (Glaswegians in fact, unlike the SPL which is currently being taken over by Irishmen). Coaching even at the very top level is about teaching, and there just don’t appear to be a lot of good English football teachers about. The best seems quite demonstrably to be Roy Hodgson, and if this were any other top European footballing nation, I think Hodgson would probably already have the job by now. They’re a funny bunch, these Europeans, they seem to have an oddly simple way of doing things, including the appointment of national team bosses: generally, they find the guy with the best track record and experience, and on that basis, subject of course to negotiation and availability, they offer him the job. International players are expected to be self-motivated and disciplined, and intelligent enough to be able to follow the coach’s instructions. Redknapp’s record is little better than McClaren’s (an FA Cup rather than a League Cup), despite the advantage of a far longer managerial career. Hodgson’s career is equally extensive and he’s worked abroad a lot, something that, dare I say, might be advantageous when it comes to understanding the motives and mentalities of England’s international rivals. But here we are told that there’s nothing more important than team spirit, and there’s nobody better than Harry Redknapp at engendering that. He’s become a kind of mythical folk hero, fans are wheeled out from God knows where to declare that he’s the only possible choice. The players want him, everybody wants him, but the real people who want him are the media because he fits their template and the media call the shots in England, whether it’s good for the team or not. England’s traditional failing, relying on a kind of mythical English team spirit, while cleverer and better organised foreigners run rings round them will be in evidence again. As I think I’ve mentioned already, I’m not an England fan so I don’t really care, but if you want to know why England lose, you can throw away Kuper and Szymanski’s book, it can all be seen in this whole sorry episode, in glorious technicolour.
This article was written for SISIF News by Stephen O’Donnell whose novel “The Road to Paradise”, a book that will be of interest to all football lovers, is to be published this year by Ringwood Publishing
Perfect Christmas presents for Football lovers
“Yellow Submarine” The ideal Christmas present for all football lovers
If you’re looking for a Christmas Present for anyone interested in football, Ringwood has the perfect solution. Almost all football fans are Romantic Dreamers (although they often hide it well). They fervently hope and believe their club, no matter how big or small, can and will do better. “Yellow Submarine- the Miracle of Villarreal CF” is the inspiring story of how a wee club from a small town of under 50,000 population rose from the lower depths of Spanish football to establish themselves in just over 10 years as one of the top clubs not just in Spain but in Europe. (Full details of the book can be found via the link on the right hand side below).
“Yellow Submarine” is a book that offers hope to all supporters of clubs both big and small that their club too can “Live the Dream”. Based on Community and Integrity, it offers a morally superior alternative to reliance on American or Russian Billionaires or Arab Dynasties.
Individual copies of Yellow Submarine, all signed by the author Sandy Jamieson, can be purchased from the website through the link below right.
Bulk orders at generous discounts, can be negotiated by email at mail@ringwoodpublishing.com .
Yellow Submarine is also available as an ebook from the Kindle Store at the bargain price of £8.04
“Celtic Submari” The perfect Christmas Present for all Celtic Supporters
Buying a Christmas Present for a Celtic supporter? Look no further! “Celtic Submari” is a positive and uplifting book that will delight any Celtic supporter. It tells how an invasion of Vila-real, a small town in Spain, by 10,000 Celtic supporters in 2004 led to a friendship that is unique in world football, and to the development of a New Model of football relationships based on affection and respect rather than hatred or bitterness. Celtic supporters everywhere can take great pride in how their example of camaraderie and good behaviour inspired the formation of the Villarreal Celtic Submari who have put their motto “Rivals for 90 minutes, Friends for Ever” into practice in Spain, Scotland and throughout Europe. The Celtic Submari have proved that football can harness the power of goodness, decency, integrity and friendship to help others and make a positive difference. The book offers a unique explanation for the undeniable reality that Celtic supporters have a much better record of behaviour abroad than Rangers supporters. It examines how some of the lessons from the Celtic Submari model can be applied in Scotland to help move away from the sectarian bitterness that too often mars Scottish football towards a more healthy model based on Celtic Submari principles. This element will also make the book of interest to everyone of any football affiliation or none, who has despaired of the current Scottish model marred by sectarian hatred.
Individual copies of “Celtic Submari”, all signed by the author Sandy Jamieson, can be purchased from this website through the link below right
Bulk orders, at generous discounts, can be negotiated by email at mail@ringwoodpublishing.com .
“Celtic Submari” will be available as an ebook from the Kindle Store from 13th December
Adriano The Emperor strikes back, in time to secure invite for title winning party, to sit on the bench
Adriano a challenger for Ronaldo's Fat Boy title
“He’s fat, he’s round, he’s worth a million pound” was the chant of praise sung by Clyde supporters open-mouthed in awe at stout Steve Clarke’s prime. Nowadays it is more likely to be applied insultingly to faded Brazilian superstars. The great Ronaldo, probably the world’s finest forward of the thirty years preceeding Messi and Ronaldo, set the standard, returning to Corinthians looking a physical parody of his once lithe self. Even with the extra weight, he still managed to do some good business for Corinthians (see LSA Post “The Fat Boy does Good”), helping them to a Sao Paulo League title and a Copa Brazil. However when it came to the tournament that Corinthians really wanted to win, the Copa Libertadores, Ronaldo and his rotund fellow legend Roberto Carlos were just not fit enough to help, and both left Corinthians within weeks of the club’s exit from the premier South American trophy, with the boos and jeers of the fans ringing in their ears. Ronaldo sensibly, hung up his boots for good. Roberto Carlos, with a different kind of good sense, set sail for one last overseas adventure with the mega rich Russians of Anzhi Makhachkalia.
The vacated Fat Boy title was quickly claimed by Adriano who arrived in Sao Paulo in March 2011 to take over Ronaldo’s mantle as the Great Hope who would lead Corinthians to title glory.
Adriano came with a great deal of history. On the positive side, his good days, in Italy with Inter Milan and with Brazil, had shown him to be as good as any centre forward in the world, a world class finisher with surprising silky skills for such a big man. Known in Brazil as the Emperor for his imperious play. But, and it is quite a but, he has a long history of off-field problems that have always prevented him sustaining his best form over any consistent period. In the last LSA mention was made of Ronaldinho’s fondness for the nightlife, in some ways quite understandable for a young male, but Adriano’s problems are of a darker hue. He has a sad history of depression linked to drinking to alleviate it, drinking at a level sufficient to count as serious alcoholism. Inter Milan were surprisingly tolerant of the increased absences from training that became linked to such a threatening pattern of drinking and depression, but eventually their tolerance ran out and in November 2007 he was sent back on loan to Sao Paulo. There in the sun and less intense pressure he played quite well and was recalled to Inter for season 2008-2009. The then Inter manager, a certain Jose Mourinho, initially coaxed some good performances out of Adriano but it did not last, and the tears, the depression and the drinking returned. In April 2009 Adriano announced he was quitting football for good. Initially he blamed it on a breakdown of his relationship with his fiancée, but slowly deeper truths emerged including an inability to come to terms with the death of his father, shot in dubious circumstances in a crime spot in Rio.
Adriano confessed that he felt very unhappy in Italy and that he had lost all pleasure in playing football. He returned to Brazil where he described himself as happy, “with my friends and my family”. His exile from first class football lasted only 26 days, before he signed a contract with his previous Brazilian club, Flamengo. With three weeks training under his belt he made a scoring debut for Flamengo and went onto to become the league’s top scorer as he helped lead Flamengo to a surprise title triumph in December 2009.
Not a great Roman Emperor
Adriano had a different approach to night life than Ronaldinho whose happy relaxed personality led him in constant search of good company and good times. Adriano linked up socially with what any sensible manager would call the wrong crowd, many of whom remembered him from his younger Rio days. By summer 2010 after increasing amounts of bad publicity around his lifestyle and especially his association with men known to be drug barons, Adriano ignored the lessons of his European past and signed up again with an Italian club, this time Roma, in a setting not known for its tranquillity. He never really managed to settle in either the team or the city. The contract he signed with Roma had a number of get-out clauses related to his performance and his behaviour, and by early March 2011 a frustrated management decided to exercise these clauses and cut their losses. Once again the supposed retirement was brief. This time it took 20 days before Adriano was revealed as a Corinthians player, with the man himself explaining in passing how Sao Paulo will be a safer place for him socially than a return to Rio would have been. Corinthians fans were delighted, most fervently believing that at just 29, Adriano had more to offer their club than the very fat Ronaldo.
However the initial enthusiasm and excitement soon turned to frustration as the obviously overweight and unfit Adriano struggled against a series of niggling injuries to get himself fit enough to finally make his trumpeted debut. Without access to their new superstar the goalscoring burden at title favourite Corinthians fell on Leidson the other top class repatriated forward. Leidson rose to the challenge and without Adriano Corinthians still looked the team most likely to win the league. Incredibly it was to be October, in the 28th round of a 38 game league, before Adriano was finally to make his competitive debut for Corinthians. He came on for the last 11 minutes. However a series of minor injuries prevented him from building on this late start and coming up to the middle of November there had been only two more substitute appearances, with no goals.
From Superstar to supersub Adriano comes off the bench to score
On 16th November Adriano declared himself fully fit again at last and he was named as a substitute for the away trip to Ceara. Despite the game being scoreless, Adriano was not given a chance by the cautious manager Tite and when Leidson was pulled off, it was a midfielder Morais that was brought on rather than Adriano. Eventually Corinthians snatched a 1-0 win. Four days later, at home to Atletico Mineiro Adriano again started the match on the bench. This time however he was eventually brought on in the 67th minute with Corinthians 1-0 down and facing a defeat that would hand the title initiative to Vasco da Gama with only two games to go. The substitution energerised the crowd, the noise generated was stupendous and somehow all the energy and excitement flowed into the Corinthians team. Adriano’s first major contribution was a brilliant assist to allow Leidson to equalise. Yet it appeared that all the energy and all the effort would not be enough as Atletico hung on desperately. Then in the very last minute Adriano struck to score a goal, taking a half chance with class and cool control to win the game for his team. As any normal football supporter would expect Adriano celebrated this first goal after so long in the most joyous fashion. That he was booked for this celebration says something about the soulless direction of the modern game. LSA would urge readers to google “Adriano goal for Corinthians” and see his impressive contribution, making one, scoring one and winning a game for his new club that surely clinched the league, leaving Corinthians two points ahead with two games to go.
Tite, in his usual pragmatic way, avoided getting caught up in the hype and come the next game, away to high-flying Figueirense, Adriano found himself back on the bench. A goal in the 66th minute by Leidson gave Corinthians the decisive advantage and when centre forward Emerson was substituted with 11 minutes to go it was not Adriano but a midfielder who was brought on. To his credit Adriano avoided any temper tantrums about his lack of action and seemed delighted just to be part of it all. A late winner by second placed Vasco da Gama over third placed Fluminense guaranteed that the title race would go down to the last day. Corinthians at home to old rivals Palmeiras only need a draw to guarantee them their 5th Brazilian Championship. It will be interesting to see what role if any Tite allows Adriano to play in the final game, but even if he spends the whole game on the bench, that dramatic last minute winner against Atletico will mean that Adriano will always be part of the story of that title win, even if he doesn’t add a single second to the 73 minutes that is currently his total contribution for the whole season.
But perhaps more importantly, he would appear to have coped with the frustration and inactivity of the past 6 months without triggering off returns to the black places that have haunted him in the past. In the week Gary Speed hung himself, and a book about Robert Enke a goalkeeper who committed suicide, deservedly won the William Hill Sports Book of the Year Award, perhaps we should all just be grateful that Adriano, who displayed a similar depression more openly than these other two, seems to have found some contentment even in a secondary role. Let us all hope that whatever contribution he can make to Corinthians almost certain title triumph will bring him some inner peace.
With one round to go in the Brazilian Championship, there are several other issues still to be decided as well as the destination of the title. Fluminense and Flamengo would appear destined to join Corinthians and Vasco da Gama as Brazil’s representatives in the 2012 Copa Libertadores, but the 5th slot is still up for grabs with Coritiba and Figueirense competing with Inter PA, Sao Paulo and Botofogo. .If Inter beat local rivals Gremio in their last game that would probably be enough to give them, winners in 2006 and 2010, another crack at the Libertadores. And mighty Cruzeiro need a home win against local rivals Atletico Mineiro to be absolutely sure of avoiding the relegation with which they have been flirting dangerously over the last few weeks. LSA regular readers will be pleased that Bahia the carnival club from Salvador have finished their first season back in the top league safe from relegation.
The next LSA will report on the final resolution of the Brazilian season next weekend.
Flamengo reborn but stumble near the finishing line. Ronaldinho recrosses his own line and smiles again for football rather than nocturnal reasons.
Flamengo - the club with 40 million supporters
Flamengo are the Brazilian club with the most supporters. An estimated 40 million of them in Rio and spread throughout Brazil make the Mengao truly the club of the people. They traditionally draw their support from the lower reaches of Brazilian society while their Rio rivals Fluminense, Vasco de Gama and Botafogo tend to be better supported by the middle classes and the power elites. Flamengo supporters tend to think of their club as the biggest and the best in the world, a claim not really validated since 1981 when they hammered Liverpool 3-0 to win the World Club Cup.
Since these glories days of Zico, Junior and company, with 3 Brazilian championships in 4 years as well as the Copa Libertadores and World Club Cup wins, Flamengo have never again threatened to lead the world elite, and in the mid years of this first decade of the 21st century, gross mismanagement by incompetent directors lead them perilously close to relegation from the Brazilian top division, a disaster which did actually happen to the other Brazilian club of the people, Corinthians of Sao Paulo, in 2007, as well as to all three of their posher Rio rivals.
Even the winning of the Brazilian League Championship in 2009 came out of the blue, with a mediocre Flamengo team being in the bottom half of the league in mid-season, until one of the 1981 team Andrade emerged as the coach to lead them to an unexpected Championship, their first since 1992. The momentum generated by Andrade’s success could not be maintained into the 2010 Copa Libertadores and Flamengo were eliminated in the quarter finals by a Chilean team, despite having put out Ronaldo’s Corinthians in the last 16 round. Andrade was rewarded for his miracle work by being summarily dismissed and then Flamengo reverted to more typical league form finishing 14th in the 2010 Brazilian League won by their deadly rivals Fluminense.
However new Directors took over the club, with a powerful woman President Patricia Amorim, slowly brought a more professional approach and determined to restore Flamengo to their due position as the pre-eminent Brazilian club.
- Ronaldinho Now a Flamego player
The corner stone of their approach was to gazump Gremio’s almost sealed deal to bring Ronaldinho back from Europe to Porto Alegre, and persuade him to sign instead for Flamengo. At one level this seemed an inspired move, Ronaldinho having been the best player in the world for the mid years of the first decade, winning World Footballer of the Year awards in 2004 and 2005. When Flamengo signed him in January 2011 he was only 30 years old and should have several years of top class football left in him. However serious question marks existed over his character and discipline, which made the transfer less obviously brilliant than it might otherwise have appeared.
In his last season with Barcelona, Ronaldinho had displayed a lack of dedicated professionalism. He rejected the authority of the coach Frank Rijkaard and led a cabal of players including Deco, Thiago Motta and Messi, astray in a series of drunken night time escapades. It took another of the Barcelona South Americans, Edmilson, to courageously denounce this situation, claiming there were black sheep aloose in the Camp Nou. Old President Juan Laporta and new Manager Guardiola agreed to slaughter all the black sheep, except for Messi, to cure the club of the sickness and indiscipline that had crept in. Removed from Ronaldinho’s malign social influence, Messi stabilised himself and reverted to being the model professional his personality is more suited to, the results of which have been enjoyed by Barcelona fans and football supporters everywhere over the past three years as he has clearly inherited Ronalidinho’s old role as “best player in the world”.
- Ronaldinho sad lonely figure on the field at Milan
Ronaldinho spent a largely miserable 30 months in Milan. Or more accurately he spent a brilliant 30months in Milan, partying almost nightly and single-handedly introducing Carnival traditions to Milan night life. He totally confirmed the correctness of Guardiola’s determination to get rid of his unprofessional approach from Barcelona. His first season in Milan was a poor one on the field, where his form and attitude lead him to being heavily criticised as an unprofessional freeloader. Things improved slightly in the second season, 2009-10, as Ronaldinho sought to restore enough form and reputation to book his flight to South Africa with the Brazilian squad. But he would spoil every brief run of sustained form with another nocturnal splurge, sometimes missing training, sometimes turning up smelling of alcohol. He did want to go to South Africa and did enough over the second half of the season to make it into Dunga’s provisional squad of 30. But Dunga, a hard player, a hard manager, a hard man, decided at the end that he would not risk the man’s reek of indiscipline contaminating his tightly controlled squad, and omitted a genuinely devastated Ronaldinho from the final 23 along with his Milan teammate and occasional dancing partner Pato.
Most Brazilian football supporters were appalled and accused Dunga of betraying the traditions of the beautiful game, in favour of dull conformity. There was much talk that Garrincha, who helped win Brazil two World Cups, was not exactly a model of sober disciplined behaviour even during tournaments. In the event, a rather flat Brazilian team exited the World Cup without distinction even though they had been well-seeded to meet Spain in the Final. They lost in the Quarter Finals to a more spirited Dutch team but it was a game Dunga’s team might well have won and a game where even a couple of minutes of Ronaldinho magic might have proved crucial.
- Ronaldinho enjoying the Milan night life too much
The disappointment of missing out on the World Cup did not prompt a disappointed Ronaldinho into a major rethink and season 2010-11 saw him reverting to the worst patterns of his initial season. AC Milan finally decided that he was a liability to them and with Ibrahimovic and Robinho now available to them up front along with a more professional Pato, Ronaldinho drifted out of the first team picture and started partying even more. Allegri the clever and talented new manager made it clear he could do without Ronaldinho and the decision was made to cut their losses and let him leave in the Winter Transfer Window without expecting an enormous fee. They replaced him in their squad with another “bad boy” Antonio Cassano whose indiscipline was of a less nocturnal nature to Ronaldinho’s. With this change settled, AC Milan romped home in the Italian League finishing 6 points ahead of neighbours Inter.
The word was clearly out in European football circles that he was finished as a top class player and even previous suitors Manchester City didn’t want to waste money subsiding the thriving Manchester night life scene.
Several Brazilian clubs, most notably his original club Gremio and fading Palmeiras decided they would like to take a gamble that his charisma and talent could kick-start them into better days again, but in the end it was the new Board at Flamengo who made the most offer, helped no doubt by the fact that Ronaldinho like most poor Brazilian boys had grown up worshipping the Red and Blacks.
While Ronaldinho was naturally the signing that got all the attention, more quietly the Directors engaged in several other repatriations that added much needed depth of quality to the side. The most talented of this group was Thiago Neves, well known to regular readers of Letters From South America as the player who almost died of a broken heart after scoring 4 goals in a Copa Libertadores Final and still finishing on the losing side, to the worst team ever to win the Copa, LDU Quito. He sought relief from the pain with exile in Europes but his shattered heart prevented him showing his true potential. Eventually he sought a different kind of solace by campaigning for Arab petro dollars and seemingly turning his back on serious football. When Fluminense, his old team, won the 2010 Brazilian Championship they determined to bring their old idol back to lead them into a further attempt on Copa Libertadores glory. For a while it looked as if they had succeeded, but to general surprise he turned up one day to be announced as a new Flamengo signing. Maybe the fact that Flamengo were not playing in the Copa Libertadores tipped the balance for this still haunted man. Also brought back from self-imposed petro dollar semi-retirement was an old Flamengo favourite midfielder Renato Abreu. He had always been a top quality player without ever getting proper international recognition and when he went East aged 30 it seemed his chances of ever playing for Brazil had gone West. They brought experienced forward Deivid back from Turkey to be their main striker. They signed ex-Corinthians goalie Felipe from Braga where he never really settled and to the delight of their younger fans brought back young defensive midfielder Airton on loan from Benfica, who had snapped him up after his starring role in the 2010 Brazilian Title victory but never managed to harnass his tigerish ability. The final addition was not a direct repatriation but class centre back Alex Silva although signed from Sao Paulo actually belonged to Hamburg. Already in the squad were experienced internationalists like Leoardo Moura and Chilean Claudio Maldonado and seasoned professionals like Junior Cesar and Ronaldo Angelim, plus a host of promising youngsters like Welinton, Willian, Diego Mauricio and Negueba.
- Vanderlei Luxemburgo the best Brazilian Manager of the past 20 years takes on restoring Flamengo to the top rank
To manage this promising mix of world class superstars, solid internationalists, good professionals and upcoming young players, the Directors turned to the most successful Brazilian manager of the past 20 years, Vanderlei Luxembourg already familiar to regular LSA readers as a great manager and a flawed man. His record over the past 20 years includes 5 Brazilian Championships, 12 State Leagues, and 1 Copa Brazil, as well as a Copa America with the national team. Al;.though he failed to shine in his one year with Real Madrid
True to his record he did not take long to weld all that talent into an effective and attractive, but not reckless, team. He gave Ronaldinho a free role up front behind sole striker Deivid and pushed Thiago Neves and Renato Abreu as wide supports with the centre policed by Airton and Willian standing in brilliantly for the seriously injured Maldonado. Flamengo swept aside all local opposition in the 2011 Rio State League winning both legs of the competition to obviate the need for a grand Final. Ronaldinho played superbly in the final of the second stage competition assisting as Thiago Neves scored both goals in the 2-0 defeat of Botafogo, and the team as a whole looked very good.
It would not be true to say that Ronaldinho completely gave up partying on his return to Flamengo but somehow he settled on a balance that was tolerated by his employers and allowed him to perform professionally on the field.
LSA predicted at the start of the Brazilian Championship that Flamengo were the only team that looked likely to challenge Corinthians for the national title and about 40 million Brazilians were scandalised at the LSA lack of faith in what they saw as a certainty, the title coming “Back Home”
Flamengo went the first 17 games without defeat but too many silly draws prevented them from converting that run without defeat into a commanding lead. The highlight of this opening run was the away game against new Copa Libertadores holders Santos who for once put out their strongest team. Santos went 3-0 up with goals from Borges(2)and new world superstar Neymar. But Flamengo showed the depth of their character and fought back to 3-3 with goals from Ronaldinho, Deivid and Thiago Neves. This heroic effort seemed in vain when Neymar put Santos back in the lead but Ronaldinho added 2 more to make his hat-trick and give Flamengo an unforgettable victory.
LSA would urge all its readers to google “Santos 4 Flamengo 5″ and watch all the goals on You Tube. All 9 goals are stunning, with one from Neymar demonstrating exactly why he is so highly rated. One of Ronaldinho’s goals is a classic freekick beneath a jumping wall and the winner is a gem of individual skill. LSA often bemoans the general low standard of Brazilian football but games like that demonstrate that at its best it can still match the quality of the top European Leagues
- Ronaldinho restored to the Brazil team, that famous smile restored for football reasons
To great popular rejoicing across all of Brazil the Ronaldinho in this form was shortly thereafter restored to the Brazilian International Squad by Mano Menezes and starred in several games. More surprising, but definitely deserved, was a first international call up for 33 year Renato Abreu. A tale that offers hope to talented players ever, “Never give up, if you have the talent miracles can happen even at a late age”. Renato Abreu went on to make his debut for Brazil against Argentina and played with style and distinction.
Buoyed by their success against Santos Flamengo rattled off a run of four consecutive victories. However from the start of September they slumped disastrously losing 4 consecutive games, two at home to poor teams they should have beaten easily. One of the away defeats was to Corinthians who were delighted to find themselves facing Flamengo in a slump. Even so it took a last minute Leidson goal to deliver Corinthians the win they needed. Luxemburgo worked hard to stop the slump, bringing in several younger fresher players and the next 8 games saw 4 wins and 4 draws, including an away win over Sao Paulo and a home win over Fluminense that both delighted their supporters. This run saw Flamengo back as serious contenders in the title race, the most likely danger to favourites Corinthians.
However the last three weeks have seem them stumble badly approaching the finishing line with 2 defeats and 2 draws in 5 games. Their last two games, tame 0-0 draws, have even seen them slip out of the Copa Libertadores slots that guarantee the top 4 clubs places in next season’s tournament. To fail to qualify would indeed be a disaster, given all the emotional and financial investment. On Sunday Flamengo are at home to direct rivals for a Libertadores place, Inter PA and really must win. They will also, unusually, be praying for a Fluminense victory that same day, since a defeat of Vasco da Gama would effectively give Corinthians the title and leave Vasco to face the last day game against Flamengo with nothing crucial to play for, except of course the joy of humiliating their rival Rio enemy.
Hopefully the Flamengo of Ronaldinho, Thiago Neves, Renato Abreu and all will gather their strength for the one final push that will see them qualified for next year’s Libertadores. That is one outcome that can be guaranteed to bring the right kind of smile back to Ronaldinho’s face. He has worked hard enough and behaved professionally enough to deserve it. He has just been confirmed in a recent Brazilian opinion poll as by far the most popular player in the country, and there will not be many football supporters anywhere in the world who would deny him the happiness that a return to top class international competition would bring him.
Tomorrow LSA will report on the finish to the Brazilian Championship and how Corinthians look clear favourites to triumph.
Corinthians need to stop being casual to clinch Brazilian title
Corinthians - the club of the people
Corinthians are popularly known as Timao, the team of the people. They are the best supported of the four big Sao Paulo clubs. Their estimated 30 million supporters are the second biggest support in Brazil behind only the 40 odd million fans of Flamengo, the Rio ‘club of the people’.
In April SISIF News confidently tipped Corinthians to emerge from the just beginning 2011 Brazilian League as the most likely Champions. And for all of the campaign to date they have either been leaders or very close in contention. Now, with only 5 games to go they sit top of the league, but they will have to cut back on an alarming tendency to casualness if they are to hold on to that number one spot and earn their 5th national title for their fanatical supporters, known as the Fiel.
The four Rio clubs, Vasco de Gama, Fluminense, Flamengo and Botafogo are the only clubs left in a position to deny the Timao the title they have set their hearts on. Currently Vasco the winners of the 2011 Brazil Cup, are behind Corinthians only on goal difference, with 2010 champions Fluminense 2 points behind, and 2009 Champions Flamengo a further point behind sharing 4th place with Botafogo.
In some ways this has appeared to be the most open and even Brazilian Championship ever, in the 8 years since the league resorted to the European formula of League football rather than the more complicated formulas of mini-leagues and knockout stages used in the first 32 years from the formation of a true national championship in 1971. But those like your SISIF News correspondent who watch Brazilian games regularly can report that the sad truth is that the increased competitiveness has resulted from a reduced standard of play which means there are no outstanding teams and almost every team is capable of beating any other team. In what would be a surprise to most UK football supporters, brought up on the myth of Brazilian brilliance, the current overall standard of even the top teams is actually quite poor, by top European standards.
Alex brought back from Russia to add class in midfield to help win the league
The pace of decline is perhaps best illustrated by Inter PA. In 2006 they won the Copa Libertadores and then went on to beat Barcelona in the 2006 World Club Cup Final, 1-0 with a goal from Alex. In 2010 Inter again won the Copa Libertadores, and then in the World Club Cup became the first South American champions to fail to reach the Final, surrendering docilely to African champions Mazembe in a woeful display. Inter Milan emphasised the weakness of that performance by hammering Matumbe 3-0 in the Final days before they sacked their Manager, Rafa Benitez, because the team were not quite right.
In the 5 years since that first Inter PA triumph, the process whereby every promising Brazilian club player is snapped up by European clubs has accelerated denuding the Brazilian League of much of its most promising talent. Even China through new champions Gangzhou have started playing this game, taking Dario Conca, the best player of the Fluminense 2010 champions side to improve the quality of their team for an irresistible fee of 10 million dollars.
Over the past few years an attempt has been made to reverse this talent drain with several high profile world class Brazilian players being lured back to the home country. Corinthians were one of the leaders of this movement with the two all-time legends Ronaldo and Roberto Carlos being brought back in time for their Centenary season. Boosted by these two stars Corinthians won the 2009 Sao Paulo State League and the 2009 Brazil Cup, then finished 3rd in the 2010 Brazilian League. However their two attempts at the Copa Libertadores in 2010 and 2011 ended dismally, and both super stars departed, Ronaldo into fat fuelled retirement and Roberto Carlos to a last major payday with the latest Russian plutocrats Anzi Makhachkala.
For their attempt on the 2011 Brazilian championship Corinthians repatriated Adriano, another fat forward with a history of personal problems. Hampered by niggling in juries and continuing personal indiscipline, Adriano has contributed almost nothing to the Championship effort, appearing for only 38 minutes in two substitute appearances without scoring.
Leidson repatriated to score goals
More successful was the signing from Sporting Lisbon of 33 year old Leidson, a Brazilian who had assimilated so well in Portugal that he gained several caps for the national side. Quickly integrated into Corinthians Leidson has provided the sharpness in front of goal that characterised his time with Sporting Lisbon, contributing 10 goals in 22 starts to be top scorer. Then more recently they added some creative flair to their midfield with the purchase of ex-Inter PA star Alex from Spartak Moscow. The best of the rest have been defensive midfielders Ralf who has established himself in the Brazilian national side and Paulinho who recently gained a first cap.
In the summer there was talk that Carlos Tevez would sign for Corinthians for a rumoured fee of £40 million pounds. Two things can be said about this proposed transfer. The first is that if Tevez had signed for Corinthians in July 2011 then it is very likely that Corinthians would have already have had the 2011 title sewn up by now. The second is that despite this sporting reality it would have been a financially disastrous move for Corinthians. It took Corinthians years to recover from the last time they signed Tevez and his international team mate Mascherano. While they did win the national title with these two in 2005, the financial difficulties created led directly to their relegation to the Second Division in 2007. That a club with 30 million supporters and Corinthians’ rich history should be relegated was almost unthinkable but it did happen, due to many factors, with the purchase of Tevez being one of them.
Carlos Tevez He would have won Corinthians the league but at too high a cost
It has been fascinating to hear in the last few days the new Sao Paulo coach, hard man Leao, reminding Corinthians fans that Tevez displayed similar problems under Leao in Corinthians in 2006 to those he is now displaying at Manchester City and that they should be wary of rushing to welcome him back even at the reduced fee of under 20 million that may be possible in the January 2012 Transfer Window. Even if they can get that kind of money Corinthians would be better advised to invest in half a dozen younger Brazilians to boost the general overall depth of quality in their side rather than risk it on the unreliable temperament of a man who has already let their club down previously and whose character has appeared to deteriorate since then. However logic and reason has little to do with the way Corinthians Football Club is run and it would be unwise to bet against this foolish transfer being made.
Even without Tevez, Corinthians should still be good enough to win this year’s League Championship. They have the easiest run-in of the top five, with three games at home and Adriano may yet make a belated contribution. The Rio teams have a series of local derbies to come in the final weeks of the season and of the four, Flamengo, with their repatriated trio of Ronaldinho, Thiago Neves and Deivid, would seem best placed to make Corinthians fight until the final day rather than Vasco Fluminense or Botafogo. At the worst, even with more of the casualness that has already led to several unexpected home defeats, Corinthians should at least ensure qualification for the 2012 Copa Libertadores since Vasco have already qualified as Brazil Cup winners and there are four places available via the top of the League.
Neymar Santos superstar hping for World Club Cup glory
Even if they do as they should, and win this year’s League, Corinthians will not be recognised as the best team in Brazil. That honour undoubtedly belongs to Santos, well deserved winners of the 2011 Copa Libertadores. With that triumph under their belt Santos relaxed in the League and will end up in mid table. But having sensibly reinforced the Libertadores winning team with stars like Elano, Henrique, Ibson and Borges, Santos on their day are a class above the rest including Corinthians. They demonstrated this in mid September beating a full strength Corinthians team 3-1 in front of their own stunned supporters. Santos have managed to hold on to superstar Neymar at least until the World Club Cup in December, where he may as a likely future Real Madrid recruit have a vested interest in ensuring they deny Barcelona the official title of best team in the world generally awarded to them by acclaim. Barcelona still have not given up hope of signing Neymar themselves, only partly to stop Real getting him. Santos claim to want to keep him at least until the 2014 World Cup but the smart money still is on a 2102 move to Real Madrid for a fee of over £50 million pounds. GGW will report on the final few weeks of the Brazilian Championship and also on Santos’s effort to repeat their achievements under Pele by winning the World Club
Yellow Submarine splits in two, Celtic Submari emerges in own right
Yellow Submarine ready to launch
?Apologies to all regular SISIF News readers for the lack of normal service over the past few months. Chief Editor Sandy Jamieson has had to concentrate exclusively on implementing the decision of Ringwood Publishing to split the book Yellow Submarine. At the end of April Ringwood Publishing took the massive decision that the story of the Celtic Submari was too major and too important to subsume within the Yellow Submarine story of the miracle of Villarreal CF. They decided it was a separate enough and important enough story to be a book in its own right. Since then he has been working very hard to separate out what was one of the three strands of the original book and ensure that he produced two books, each of which stands separately, although they are companion volumes.
As a result there are now two books to show for the last 3 years of his life.
One is the “Yellow Submarine – the Miracle of Villarreal CF” At £11.99 it will remain excellent value, offering two stories for the price of one. Part One provides an explanation for the miracle of Villarreal CF including identifying the 10 Key Ingredients that best explain how a wee club from a small town of under 50,000 population has become one of the top teams not just in Spain but in Europe.
Part Two is the account of a three year voyage on the Yellow Submarine as they set sail in search of further glory in the Champions League, the Europa League and La Liga. It explores how the key ingredients identified in Part One are applied in practice and whether the lessons from Villarreal are replicable for small and medium sized clubs throughout Europe.
Celtic Submari Launching in its own right
The other book is “Celtic Submari – a new model of football relationships, based on affection and respect, not hatred, bitterness or sectarianism.” In publishing this Ringwood Publishing has recognised that the story of how an invasion of Vila-real by 10,000 Celtic supporters in 2004 led to the amazing and unique friendship between supporters of Villarreal and Celtic deserves to be told in its own right, separate from the story of the Miracle of Villarreal CF.
Celtic supporters everywhere can take pride in the story of how their example of camaraderie and good behaviour inspired the formation of the Villarreal Celtic Submari which has proved to be an extraordinary example of the way in which decent people can help others through football and friendship.
Celtic Submari will also explore why the subsequent visit of Glasgow Rangers to Vila-real did not result in a similar outburst of mutual friendship but continued the pattern of significantly different behaviour abroad of the two Old Firm sets of supporters. The book will offer an explanation of the cultural and other differences that lie behind these different behaviours.
It will show why both Celtic and Rangers supporters need to learn some of the lessons from the model practised by the Villarreal Submari if Scottish football is ever to eradicate the sectarian sickness that currently erodes its soul.
This book will retail at £9.99. For every book sold £2 will be donated to the Villarreal Celtic Submari charity.
I can at last provide a definite date for the launch of both books. It will take place on Saturday 17th September 2011 from 7pm to 10pm in the Celtic Supporters Association Social Club at 1524 London Road, by Celtic Park. Please put the date and time and venue in your diary now. Please also feel free to invite anyone you think might be interested in these books. The programme for the launch has not been completely determined yet but it will be around the content of the books and several current and former Celtic legends hopefully will be in attendance. Celtic do not have a game that day but they play Rangers at Ibrox the next day so the themes of “Celtic Submari” should be quite topical.
The very good news is that Ernesto and Maria Dolores Boixader have agreed to attend the launch. Saul Ramos is coming too and others of the Celtic Submari may come over as well.
Further details of both books, including how to pre-order them, and of the launch can be found on the Publisher’s web site at www.ringwoodpublishing,com
Now that the writing and editing o f the two books is finished, normal service will resume
Santos and Velez, the two favourites head for a classic Copa Libertadores Brazil versus Argentina Final clash
Velez head for the Copa Libertadoes semi-finals and lead the Argentinean League
After the shocks of the previous round all 4 Copa Libertadores Quarter finals went as predicted in the last Letter from South America. The two favourites Santos and Velez Sarsfield are still on course to make it a classic Argentina versus Brazil clash in the Final. Velez Sarsfield had the easier victory in the Quarter Finals seeing off Libertad of Paraguay 3-0 in the home leg before travelling to Paraguay to administer a 4-2 thrashing for a convincing 7-2 aggregate victory. The current team are more offensive than previous Velez sides, who have tended to be dour and defensive. Coach Ricardo Gareca has Velez set up very offensively with striking double act of recent Argentina cap Menendez and the prolific Uruguayan Santiago Silva well supported from midfield by small but tricky Maxi Morales, the skilful and mature Zapata and new signing Ramirez. Interestingly, Gareca has decided to depart from the usual Libertadores pattern of fielding weakened sides in the weekend league games in a determined effort to land a league and Libertadores double. Just 3 days after the second Libertad game, a full strength Velez side won comfortably in the League to put themselves 3 points clear. Read more
The Slaughter of the Complacent Brazilians
Penarol eliminate the complacent holders Inter PA
Wednesday 4th May 2011 will enter Brazilian football history as one of the nation’s blackest nights ever. All 4 of their representatives in the Copa Libertadores in action that night lost, 3 from situations that had seemed eminently winnable after the first leg ties. Never before in the history of premier Club Cup competition, either in South America or Europe, has a country lost 4 representatives in the one night.
The most prominent casualty, the greatest shock, was the defeat of the competition favourites Cruzeiro in their own stadium. Cruzeiro had done the hard part, in the first leg, going to Colombia and beating previous holders Once Caldas 2-1 in their own stadium. For the return leg in Belo Horizonte they were without their 3 star forwards, Wallyson, Thiago Ribeiro and Brandao recently repatriated from Marseille in the wake of a sex scandal. Imagine Manchester United without Rooney, Hernandez and Berbatov. Or Barcelona without Messi, Villa and Pedro. Or Real Madrid without Adebayor, Benzema and Higuian. Oh woops, Mourinho chose to be without those three for his home game against Barcelona, and lost. Read more
Copa Libertadores comes to life, after slow start
Cruzeiro light up Copa Libertadores with impressivve win
This week the eyes of the eyes not just of Europe but the whole world have been focused on the dramatic confrontation in the European Champions League between the two Spanish giants Real Madrid and Barcelona. Meanwhile back in South America, their equivalent tournament, the Copa Libertadores has much more quietly begun to waken up after a deadly quiet first 3 months.
Over the last three days all 8 of the First Knockout Round first leg ties have been played and by this time next week all the Quarter-Finalists will be known. The relative weakness of the South American club champions was exposed last December in the World Club Cup competition, when for the first time ever, the Copa Libertadores champions did not feature in the Final. Inter PA were eliminated at the semi-final stage by the African champions Mazembe, in a result that sent shock waves of fear, alarm shame and recrimination reverberating throughout the South American continent. There will considerable extra pressure on the 2011 Copa Libertadores Champions to redeem the reputation of their continent with victory in this year’s World Club Cup. Yet not a bookie in the world is likely to have the European representatives, now almost certain to be either Barcelona or Manchester United, as anything other than massive odds on favourites to provide another European triumph.
So who are likely to emerge as the Continent’s standard holders with the unenviable task of stopping either Barcelona or Manchester United from making it an record equalling 5 wins a row for Europe? Read more
Normal service is resumed as the Yellow Submarine heads to dry dock
Yellow Submarine almost home a d dry
SISIF News apologises to all its readers for the break in service the last few months while the Chief Editor, Sandy Jamieson has been obsessively finalising his work on his book “Yellow Submarine the miracle of Villarreal CF and a voyage in search of integrity, community and friendship in football” The decision of Ringwood Publishing to defer publication of the book in order to ensure it covers the whole of season 2010-11 has been strongly vindicated by the astonishing success of Villarreal in the knock out rounds of the Europa League. In successive rounds, they have eliminated the second placed teams in Serie A and the Bundesliga, and the league leaders in Holland. Hopefully over the next 10 days they will eliminate Porto the champions of Portugal before meeting and beating the second best team in Portugal, Benfica, in the final in Dublin on the 18th May. 18th May just happens to be the day of Saint Pasqual, Vila-real’s patron saint.
But even if they are eliminated by Porto, this season’s achievements still add a Europa League semi-final to the list of Champions League semi-final and quarter final and UEFA Cup semi-final and quarter final places already achieved by this amazing little club in the last 7 years.
In addition season 2010-11 should also see Villarreal qualify once more for the Champions League for season 2011-12.
So the last two chapters of the book are not yet written and hopefully will not becompleted finally until the 19th May with both the Europa League trophy and the Champions League qualification in the bag. In that case the cover will be altered to show both Fernando Roig and Santi Cazorla holding up Villarreal’s first ever trophy.
“Yellow Submarine” is essential reading for all football fans who believe that integrity, community and friendship can and should matter even at the highest levels in modern football.
It is exceptional value, offering Three Books for the Price of One
Book One The Miracle of Villarreal CF
The explanation of how a wee club from a small town of 50,000 inhabitants became a major force not just in Spain but in Europe, including becoming Semi-Finalists in the Champions League, the UEFA Cup and the Europa League, and Runners Up in La Liga. The amazing success of Villarreal offers supporters of clubs both large and small throughout Europe a model of how they too might live the dream, without having to rely on Russian or American billionaires or Arab dynasties.
Book Two Rival for 90 minutes, Friends for Always
The heart-warming story that explains how an invasion of Vila-real by 10,000 Celtic supporters in 2004 created a set of circumstances that has led to a lasting friendship between supporters of Villarreal and Celtic that is unique in world football and which still offers a model of camaraderie and togetherness that shows how football can be a force for good.
Book Three The Inside Account of a three year voyage on the Yellow Submarine as they set sail in search of further glory in the Champions League, Europa League and La Liga, encountering teams like Manchester United and Arsenal, Celtic, Barcelona and Real Madrid, and Porto on the way
Target Audiences
Explanations of the Miracle “Yellow Submarine” will be of considerable interest to all lovers of football who have struggled to understand how a small club from a town of under 50,000 inhabitants has established itself as one of the most successful clubs in Europe. In the past 8 seasons Villarreal have been semi finalists and quarter finalists in the Champions League; semi-finalists and quarter-finalists in the UEFA Cup; and semi finalists in the Europa League, while establishing themselves as one of the Big Six clubs in Spain.
It is also a story of amazing community involvement in a football club, with the number of season tickets holders representing over 40% of the population, a figure unprecedented in world football. Villarreal have by far the highest percentage of female season ticket holders, some 30%, of any major club. The Villarreal youth section has 7,000 members. In the Villarreal crowds, adult males are a minority.
A heart warming tale of how football can be a force for good
“Yellow Submarine”
will also appeal to all those interested in the power of decency, integrity and friendship to make a positive difference in a complex world through football.
Celtic supporters everywhere can rightly take pride in the story told in Book 2 as to how their example of camaraderie and good behaviour in 2004 inspired the formation of the Villarreal Celtic Submari which has proved to be an extraordinary example of the way in which decent people can help others through football and friendship.
The remarkable friendship between Celtic Supporters and Villarreal supporters has continued to grow, and inspire, many years on.
Book 2 also explores why the subsequent visit of Glasgow Rangers to Villarreal did not result in a similar outburst of mutual friendship. Book 2 provides a unique and never previously published explanation of the cultural and other differences between Celtic and Rangers supporters that explains their radically different behaviours abroad. It offers an enhanced understanding of some of the elements of the sectarian sourness that so scars Scottish football and suggests radical solutions drawing on the Villarreal model.
Pre-Ordering a copy of the Yellow Submarine
“Yellow Submarine” will have a cover price of £14.99, a remarkable price for a collection of three books in one.
However Ringwood Publishing is making a prepublication offer to reserve signed copies of the book to be delivered in advance of official publication for the exceptional price of £12.
A link will soon be provided to allow copies of Yellow Submarine to be ordered directly from theSISIF News site but for now
PrePublication copies of “Yellow Submarine can be ordered in two ways
1) from the Ringwood website, www.ringwoodpublishing.com by credit card
2) by letter and cheque to Ringwood Publishing, PO Box 16298, Glasgow G13 9DD
Normal service will contine with the next post being a Letter from South America about progress in this year’s Copa Libertadores
